Skip to main content

Book Review: Walk on Earth a Stranger

Title: Walk On Earth a Stranger
Author: Rae Carson
Series: Gold Seer Trilogy #1
Length: 432 pages
Published by: Greenwillow Books
Publication Date: September 22, 2015
Diversity: Biracial major character (half Cherokee, half white), minor black character, multiple minor gay characters
Rating:




This book was a lovely surprise. I was expecting to like it - I'd heard mostly good things about it, and I usually like historical fiction. But this book blew me away. I barely put it down. And now I want more people to read it so I have more people to talk about it with.

I think that this book's main strength was its characters. Every single character was fleshed out very well. I did have trouble keeping track of a few of the minor characters, just because of the sheer number of people in the story and the fact that I'm awful of keeping track of names, but that didn't make the plot hard to understand. I loved Lea and Jeff (of course), and I really liked Therese, too. And Mrs. Joyner surprised me.

Speaking of characters, let's talk about how surprisingly great the diversity was. I would have been a bit disappointed if this book had no diverse characters, but it exceeded my expectations. There are two characters of color, and the racism against them is addressed in what I thought was a really great way. It was made clear that this prejudice was important and inescapable, but it wasn't a let's-stop-everything-to-talk-about-it kind of thing. It just went along with daily life, which is probably what would have happened. For the gay characters, even though their sexualities are only brought up in one conversation and not blatantly spelled out, the meaning of 'confirmed bachelor' is pretty clear. And there's a full explanation in the author's note, too.

I was a bit worried that the slight fantasy aspect in this book would make me like it less, but it fit in very well. Lea's ability to sense gold almost felt natural. Throughout the entire book, I never even had to acknowledge no, nothing like that could ever really happen, but that I was reading about it anyway. I did appreciate that it wasn't a main focus, and even though it's what got the plot going, there was also so much that didn't depend on it at all. And wow, was there a lot going on in the plot.

This book always kept me on my toes. There was always so much going on, but I was never confused by what was happening. Cross-country journeys were dangerous, and I was always very aware of that when I was reading. I never knew when something bad was going to happen. (And bad things happened. I honestly don't know why I wasn't expecting more of that.) And even with all of the unexpected things, everything still fit together perfectly.

In case any of you are inspired to go and read this book RIGHT AWAY (which I highly recommend), just keep in mind that the sequel, Like a River Glorious, isn't out until November. (And it has just as beautiful of a cover as this one!) It's definitely become one of my most anticipated books of this year! But I wish it weren't on that list so that I could have it in my hands now. Anticipating is great. Reading is better.

What are some of your favorite Gold Rush/westward expansion books? Have you ever read a book that's historical fiction mixed with fantasy? Are you going to read Walk On Earth a Stranger now? Tell me in the comments! 

Comments

  1. Historical fiction mixed with fantasy sounds like my cup of tea, to be no honest. I also love that racism it's addressed! Great review :D

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. If you like historical fiction and fantasy, DEFINITELY read this! I was skeptical, but it all felt so natural that I hardly noticed that the gold-sensing ability wasn't something that would have actually existed. (Probably.)

      Delete
  2. I thought the synopsis sounds intriguing, but this review makes me want to read it even more! Diversity, historical fiction, and fantasy sound like my kind of book, and glad to hear the characters are awesome too!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Read it! If you like diversity, historical fiction, and fantasy, then I think you'll REALLY like this. I need more people to love this book so I can talk about it more.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

February Wrap-Up

I'm gonna be honest here : February's been rough. I'm surprised that I g ot a whole month's worth of posts up. I can 't really go into all the details right now, but the biggest thing is that I've had a migraine for almost two month s now and it's really getting in the way of me doing things. I've been to the doctor and gotten an MRI , but we're still w a iting on the results . So that's been messing with everything else in my life. Reading-wise, that means tha t I've been turning to audiobooks a lot. There are times that I literally don't have the energy to do anythi ng more than lie in the dark, but with audiobooks, I can get some amount of reading done even then. If you guys ha ve an y audiobook recomm endations, send them my way!   THE BOOKS PRODIGY by Marie Lu (Legend #2): I didn't like this one as much as LEGEND. I didn't think the plot was as interesting, and it was also pretty predictable. It set up the ...

My Ten Most Disappointing Reads

As I've read more books, I've generally gotten better at telling whether I'm going to like a book before I read it. Sometimes, though, books trick me - I look at them, think I'm going to love them, and then I don't. That really annoys me, but it makes for good post material - basically, this whole post is going to be me venting about books I really wanted to love. THE WINNER'S CURSE by Marie Rutkoski: I heard so many great things about this series - I still do - and I just don't get it. I read the first book, and I didn't care about anything that was going on, and at this point, there's no way that I'm finishing the series. DASH & LILY'S BOOK OF DARES by Rachel Cohn & David Levithan: I couldn't even finish this one, and you guys know how rarely I DNF books. I thought this was going to be a really cute holiday story, and I've really liked other David Levithan books, but by the time I was just a few chapters in I ...

Thoughts on Required Reading, Part 2

Last year, I did a post about my thoughts on required reading. This is a rough follow-up to that. It's that time of year again - the start of a new semester! I know my school starts later than most, so if you're a student, you've probably already started. But I just started my classes a couple of days ago...which explains why my Friday post is going up on a day that's definitely not Friday. (Oh, well.) It also means that it's the perfect time to talk about required reading again. Quick recap of the last post: I was required to reread PRIDE AND PREJUDICE , which I'd originally read on my own and loved, and hated it. Update: last semester, I was required to reread THE GREAT GATSBY , another book that I'd originally loved. But this time, the required reread made me love the book even more. But I can't put my finger on anything that made rereading the two books different, except for the fact that I already knew I wanted to reread Gatsby at some p...